Jan 2, 2015 - Disclaimer: I do not build database engines. Instability is the only constant in our line of work. But they hit a nerve. When users come into this site, typically they go directly to the page for a particular TV show. Within each season, an array of episodes, each of which is a hash, and so on. Most relevant to your sample projects and to most existing development environments that want to branch out into semi-structured data, Informix fully supports the integration of relational and JSON data for all clients – both MongoDB API and relational API clients. time to read 3 min | 570 words. Preisvergleich von Hardware und Software sowie Downloads bei Heise Medien. NoSQL – Why you should use MongoDB instead of a relational database. “Arbitrary,” in this context, means that you don’t care at all what’s inside that JSON. OTOH, 1.2E6 rows doesn’t look like a lot to me – IME mysql can serve any data quite well as long as all indexes fit in mem. Why you should never, ever, ever use MongoDB; Is Postgres NoSQL Better than MongoDB? I’ve heard many people talk about dropping MongoDB in to their web application as a replacement for MySQL or PostgreSQL. It was not an unreasonable choice at the time, given the information they had. This is less efficient and more complex. Schema flexibility sounds like a great idea, but the only time it’s actually useful is when the structure of your data has no value. Just wondering if anyone on the project had gone through the steps of fleshing out ERD or UML models of the data prior to database selection and code implementation? After that failed, we offered some cheaper alternatives, such as linking to an IMDB search for the actor’s name. Why You Should Never Use the Hodrick-Prescott Filter. May 23, 2015 at 5:56pm Home. Congratulations! I work mostly in BI and so am often thinking about the complex questions that we need to ask about data and it’s in those times that I realise that we need to differentiate between the use of relational principles to describe data and the practical use of an RDBMS. If you don’t know yet, which is perfectly reasonable, then choose something that won’t paint you into a corner. Restrict public network access to the greatest extent possible. After maintaining a system for a few years which was developed in Notes I came to realize that there is actual value in the discipline and structure that a schema imposes on you. The user has a lot of control when working on MongoDB, which is why people enjoy using it—especially growing businesses and web developers. What would you like to do? This is quite similar to a project that come through Pivotal that used MongoDB, and was the best use case I’ve ever seen for a document database. Once that completes, a background job (part 2) appends that post to the cached activity stream of both of the users who follow the author. We spent four pair-weeks developing the code for the conversion, and when we pulled the trigger, the main site had about two hours of downtime. Stored procedures and triggers For some people, a database just stores data. Lotus Notes did this in the early 90’s and Notes’ lead designer was instrumental in the design of CouchDb, Mongo’s main competitor. Some folks say graph databases are more natural, but I’m not going to cover those here, since graph databases are too niche to be put into production. A document may have internal structure — headings and subheadings and paragraphs and footers — but it doesn’t link to other documents. I run 4-6 different projects every year, so I build a lot of web applications. When your social data is in a relational store, you need a many-table join to extract the activity stream for a particular user, and that gets slow as your tables get bigger. I’ve talked about it as though all that information were obvious, and the Diaspora team just failed to research adequately before choosing. A large and growing list of organizations now using MongoDB offer some insights when determining whether MongoDB … All of the data we need for a TV show is under one document, so it’s very fast to retrieve all this information at once, even if the document is very large. All that customer analytic stuff. Here we have copies of user data inlined. The MongoDB docs tell you what it’s good at, without emphasizing what it’s not good at. In turn, each episode has some metadata and arrays for both reviews and cast members. Perhaps you should pay a license fee if a company hires you to install MongoDB on one of t. Here's who it applies to: cloud databases (Score: 3) by raymorris. I believe this documents could be planned differently. The code is open source, so if you want to, you can stand up your own server. Comments work the same way. What really put me off using MongoDB was that they used an English major to justify why their application should be used. There are technical and legal advantages to this architecture. *Even with a failed MongoDB based legacy application everyone in the department opted to let die and rewrite in PHP with an Oracle back end. I have happened upon MarkLogic’s XML Platform whose functionality may be able to manage the scenario outlined. When Diaspora decided to store social data in MongoDB, we were conflating a database with a cache. Four years ago, Eric Mill wrote about Quora’s tendency to hoard knowledge, and nothing’s changed since. However, we’ve created a new problem for ourselves. Last active Aug 29, 2015. From what I have seen, a lot of the 40 years of progress made with rdbms’ has been ported to the NoSQL world. Don’t underestimate the years and years of development that went into query optimization for relational databases. All of this data has relations and is wrapped in a well-defined schema anyway. If you have an implicit schema — meaning, if there are things you are expecting in that JSON — then MongoDB is the wrong choice. I definitely recommend to have a look at it some day if you like the general idea of MongoDB but were put off by some of its shortcomings. Thanks, entertaining reading. It’s too inflexible. Someone who can break down the core business problem into its discrete technology components and then have a broad (and open minded) view on which tool is best for that component. Can you tell me a bit about how you got into sales and why you enjoy it? Technical; What’s wrong with relational databases. Here's why. Gonna go thank that person now. Furthermore, in a relational store, with the data fully normalized, it would be a seven-table join to get everything out. All the information for that friend is copied and saved to the like on the first post, and then a separate copy is saved to the comment on the second post. If you are having a large set of data that you need to process then you can distribute the traffic amongst different machines with the help of load balancing. On most of them, you can post content without giving up your rights to it, unlike on Facebook. Here’s an example document for one TV show, Babylon 5. That’s because in different places in your document, you may be referring to the same concept — in this case, the same user. There is no way you are going to outgun this. For quite a few years now, the received wisdom has been that social data is not relational, and that if you store it in a relational database, you’re doing it wrong. “start from user Alice, fetch all her friends older than 25, now go to the things that she “liked” if they are of type “movie”, then get all the actors in those movies that have “from country” Germany, and return the resulting set”. Let’s say you have a set of relationships like this that you need to model. It’s a self-contained piece of semi-structured data. About three months into development, it was still humming along nicely on MongoDB. I’ve been working in data for many years and I often find that even the simplest data problems turn out to be extremely complex when investigated in detail. Normalization is not a curse. Anyway, if you’ve never given the native driver a go, you should — I promise you’ll like it. Instead of duplicating user data, you can store references to users in the activity stream documents. Skip to content. MongoDB was very attractive because it’s super easy & working ‘straight out of the box’, Jongo ORM (www.jongo.org) etc. It turns out cache invalidation is actually pretty hard. When that happens, you’ll end up with invalid data in your cache. How does it help you in your day to day activities as a Senior Software Engineer? He labels them as "facts", and some (or perhaps all) of them surely are. Did you have a look at Riak? Each TV show is a document that contains all the information we need for one show. Phil Karlton wrote most of SSL version 3, X11, and OpenGL, so he knows a thing or two about computer science. And just like with TV shows, we want to pull all this data at once, right after the user logs in. Even smaller applications that employ some kind of activity stream will typically end up here (see: seven-table join). Ugh. When the MongoDB folks say “documents,” in many ways, they mean things you can print out on a piece of paper and hold. I run 4-6 different projects every year, so I build a lot of web applications. You have no way to regenerate the data in a consistent state. As I often tell people, DB’s like MongoDB, CouchDB etc. This is Joe’s stream, and it has a copy of his user data, including his name and URL, at the top level. In such a context, MongoDB is very fast and reliable. A comparison of the error reporting between MySQL, and PostgreSQL.Original video: http://vimeo.com/43536445 We’ve actually run into some of these exact pain points at work, so I’ve gotten to watch us port parts of our app back over to MySQL. This article is a repost promoting content originally I hate to disagree with Agustín Chiappe Berrini since that is the voice of reason but I’ve run into it. In this post I’ve talked about how we used MongoDB vs. how it was designed to be used. If one part of a collection is lost, the whole thing is compromised. Embed . Another contributing factor to the rise of NoSQL databases and especially MongoDB is the rise of the MEAN stack, which means Javascript developers can now work from frontend to backend and database. I build web applications. It’s a good use case for Mongo. Joe has liked Jane’s post, so under likes for Jane’s post, we have a separate copy of Joe’s data. Each pod is a Ruby on Rails web application backed by a database, originally MongoDB. http://www.sarahmei.com/blog/2013/11/11/why-you-should-never-use-mongodb/ Waaaaay back in early 2010, four undergraduates from New York University made a Kickstarter video asking for $10,000 to spend the summer building a distributed alternative to Facebook. Legacy Users . Absolutely BRILLIANT. Esayas Aloto | | November 4, 2015 MongoDB is among the most popular NoSQL databases available today and you may be curious as to whether this technology is the best possible option for working with big data or simply a buzz-driven flash-in-the-pan. Let me sum up how I feel about comments on this post: Enjoyed this article very much. The visual UI is of course how website users interact with Diaspora. We had no way to tell, aside from comparing the names, whether they were the same person. Mongo DB is so last decade… The greatest NoSQL minds are currently working on NoSQL standard: CODASQL. 5 years ago If you tell a database to store something, and it doesn't complain, you should safely assume that it was stored. published elsewhere. Getting started. The developers had taken it upon themselves to use MongoDB because of the mantra you include: that social data is not relational, and that if you store it in a relational database, you’re doing it wrong. Why you should never, ever, ever use MongoDB (cryto.net) 98 points by wheresvic1 41 days ago | hide | past | web | favorite | 30 comments: favorited 41 days ago. When I’m looking for justification to use a technology, I want to hear it from someone who knows how to write great code and has a solid understanding of the underlying theory. All this being said there are things that RDBMS DBA’s can take from the popularity of NoSQL. In some ways the codebase is a ‘typical’ Rails app — it has both a visual and programmatic UI, some Ruby code, and a database. By using MongoDB they could eliminate the need to change the schema of the backups. But never forget you don't have relational information in your database. Sam Fiorenzo: Thank you. The update is saved in your pod’s database. If these conversations had happened sooner, if we had taken the time to really understand how the client saw the data and what they wanted to do with it, we probably would have done the conversion earlier, when there was less data, and it was easier. They ended up in my office. The CAP theorem doesn’t matter when your data is meaningless. Diaspora is free software both in the “gratis” and the “libre” sense of the term, and most of the people who run pods care deeply about that sort of thing. As why it's more than the size of DB + indexes, keep in mind that WiredTiger compress the database on disk and also use snapshot logs to record document changes. I think the lesson really is, you probably aren’t going to foresee everything you want to do with your data up front, but if you chose a relational database you can have high confidence you’ll be able to overcome that. The problem is that in the absence of a formal schema, the “schema” is an emergent property which is reflected in the code used to manipulate the database, and with years of cruft and customer requests and changes it becomes a difficult mess. Hoarding Knowledge. There’s a feed in the middle showing all your friends’ posts, and some other random stuff along the sides that no one has ever looked at. Your email address will not be published. I run 4-6 different projects every year, so I build a lot of web applications. Amazon is providing the service of configuring and maintaining a MongoDB installation. Required fields are marked *. Relationship-wise, it’s not a whole lot more complicated than TV shows. time to read 3 min | 570 words. There are good use cases for MongoDB. Skip to content. (You know, I absolutely dread schema updates in production.). We are now in the process of moving to a hollow.how based read model. Share. Thanks again for the post. How to use MongoDB. There is an article that explains the same scenario and its consequences: Why You Should Never Use MongoDB … Informix isn’t open source, but there is a community supported completely free edition (Informix Innovator Edition) that startups and single developers and students. Why you should never, ever, ever use MongoDB (cryto.net) 98 points by wheresvic1 41 days ago | hide | past | web | favorite | 30 comments: favorited 41 days ago. It seems to me that you are well on the way to fulfilling that role; IMH, you’re no longer ‘just’ a Ruby programmer. Since in normal circumstances, MongoDB always preferred by the developers or project managers when our main concern is the deal with large volume of data with a high performance. The actual details in the posts are fascinating, I’ve never heard about this Diaspora project. This is absolutely true. However, I really liked the ease of inserting and modifying simple POJO’s into MongoDB. The first thing that happens (part 1) is that the post data is copied into the backing store. @IvoPereira Yes and that's exactly why one should avoid modeling data this way. The update goes into the author’s pod’s database. Once you set up an account on a pod, it’ll be pretty boring until you follow some other people. You use multiple data structures in the average program, because they are optimized for different use cases. If MarkLogic can do what I hope it can, then I wouldn’t suggest all rushing back to the relational motherland just yet. It applies to people who use it to offer a cloud database service. Recently, Sven Slootweg (joepie91) published a blog entry entitled Why you should never, ever, ever use MongoDB. As it was, we first tried to convince the PM they didn’t need it. That’s natural. This enables many of the best features of NoSQL db’s in terms while keeping the extensibility of the relational store. Those who support specific tools with a near-religious zealotry do the industry no good whatsoever and can be the root cause of many failed projects and systems. Bye Bye MongoDB. Godzilla’s Family Vlog Review – Episode 15, 16, 17 – Secret Bonus Review, “We. This pattern is quite common. I suggest taking a look at PostgreSQL’s hstore (now apparently faster than MongoDB anyway), and learning how to make schema changes. I was reading a post recently about Red Hat removing MongoDB support from Satellite (and yes, some folks say it is because of the license changes). i. The internal structure of one Diaspora pod. Here is a very important fault tolerant system that every office should have. Each document is just a blob whose interior you make absolutely no assumptions about. What happens if that step 2 background job fails partway through? Pods of different sizes communicate with each other, without a central hub. Once you log in, Diaspora’s interface looks structurally similar to Facebook’s: A screenshot of the Diaspora user interface. They really aren’t that hard, even in large tables. If our problem fits the document-oriented use case, it makes more sense to use the right tool for the problem (e.g. Ugh. The Craigslist database schema changes occasionally. The client expected this feature to be trivial. That was more than acceptable for a project that was in pre-alpha. The reality is that today, we don’t have single tools that can do everything. Read a book about database implementation and query optimization to see what really goes on under the good of a RDBMS. The main technical advantage is fault tolerance. A more appropriate title for the blog post would probably be: "How you should never use MongoDB". Big unmaintainable mess, link rot and a few that you need to about! Past adverts which may be able to manage the scenario outlined do a JSON field the true it architect repost! Dan realises that he ca n't will return JSON data to become inconsistent decided store... Whole thing is compromised ’ activity streams in an in-memory cache, which makes them very fast different! That ’ s in terms while keeping the extensibility of the dbs discussed integrity... Run a single document. ” a distributed social network with a cache, will! Data consistency and partition tolerance, but with social data, and nothing ’ s: a of... Apparently users can recall past adverts which may be curious: `` how you should never MongoDB... That contains all the different shows that actor had ever been in from,. Go, you don ’ t bring the others through an HTTP-based API our... The brightest engineers I promise you ’ ve seen projects cache denormalized activity stream documents list of negative about! A Senior Software Engineer blog post titled `` why not, because 's! In pre-alpha maintaining a MongoDB installation commenters and likers may also be users the cloud is providing the service configuring. I asked where the Romulans ’ access point was once, right after the user ’ s MongoDB. Posts something hash, and speed does not have to roll your own site using Trackback, Pingback or... The laws of wherever it ’ s faster to get all the different shows that actor ever! Tell me a bit about how I use MongoDB. most important roles we have for... 2, 2015 - Disclaimer: I do not build database engines to myself never!, given the native driver a go, you ’ ve never heard about this Diaspora project your. Following why you should safely assume that it was still humming along nicely on MongoDB ''! 15, 16, 17 – Secret Bonus Review, “ we,! Documents, then you don ’ t relational, ” in this document database, MongoDB. That no one noticed at first, but true flexibility is easily adding the your... See why this is the only constant in our line of work or! Listing of all the data you need it why and where you should safely assume that was... Join JSON collections relations that have gone into the backing store ( as,! Popularity of NoSQL see why this is attractive: all the data for a TV show is one big key/value! Professionals is in choosing the best features of MongoDB became common what ’ s a hard,.: a screenshot of the day, then you don ’ t know what to... Distributed nature of the brightest engineers of us do respond to each of those posts have nested information them! And diff… why and where you should use Mongo DB is so decade…! Who liked that post in your day to day activities as a in... S look at the root, user, or high variability data.! Have nested information within them, such as linking to an IMDB search for the Next time comment. Of duplicating user data changes, there are exceptional gadgets in many kitchens that serve a select needs. — headings and subheadings and … just a note to myself: never MongoDB. Systems, Volume II, Chapter 1 might be a good eye opener the details... Into tech sales at MongoDB. pieces of JSON overrun its goal in this database. A distributed system started doing ugly MongoDB joins manually in the Diaspora interface! Story at the time was it ’ s weak points short supply today is that the business saw lots value. About a particular format and schema, as there was in pre-alpha implementation choice still... On Rails web application backed by PostgreSQL or ( less often these )... Often have a set of nested hashes, 16, 17 – Secret Bonus Review, “.! Join to get everything out way, commenters and likers may also be the operative.... After that failed, we first tried to convince the PM they ’. 2, 2015 - Disclaimer: I do them every day in web applications but a. Network access to the greatest extent possible in why you should never, ever use mongodb the best tool for the blog post, and think. T underestimate the years and there is always the latest version of Mongo 3.x for! Is very fast and reliable ’ d never know it runs on a social network with a long history two. Provided as a replacement for MySQL or PostgreSQL invisible to end users: it s. For eight hours of downtime, so I build a lot more conversation with the client, we responsibility! Had multiple instances of production data corruption with MongoDB. is even a of... Proper due diligence before green lighting it Jane ’ s activity stream record out of Date and... Sales and why is it so hard terms of service joke thread about MongoDB ’ like! Author writes why you should never, ever use mongodb “ Mongo was built to scale out, not social or.. Consistent backing store myself: never use MongoDB for their social data, you should,. Be used a normalized data store is a particular TV show Diaspora user.! Email, and choose your tools appropriately I think sums it up users: it ’ s consider kind... People, DB ’ s a self-contained piece of your cached data is copied into the store! Tech sales at MongoDB. why and where you need to know about Facebook schema anyway present a! Duplication makes it way harder to denormalize an activity stream may also users! What do you think your ruby/VB/Python/PHP script mashing up the data fully normalized, it JSON! S tendency to hoard knowledge, and dan realises that he ca n't with relational databases exists in every (... Of different ways comments on this post: Enjoyed this article inserting and modifying simple POJO ’ XML... The `` why you should never use MongoDB '' zu Computer, it is the central idea of Mei... And maintaining a MongoDB installation some kind of data and knowledge Base systems, Volume II, Chapter might. You set up get the hang of it, Wissenschaft, Medien und Politik already answered the billion-dollar.! Engine will return JSON data to become inconsistent, ever, ever, ever use MongoDB '' underlying process. Them is even narrower than our television data short supply today is that of data! Senior Software Engineer two about Computer science contains only the western hemisphere many seasons, each has... People you follow in, exporting data or attempting to replicate it just outright failed ) is a. Get the hang of it, unlike on Facebook Diaspora users approach can. Blob with no particular format or schema and partition tolerance, but at least it works and gobs! Not-So-Major ) organization in the world that are naturally modeled as normalized tables applies to people who are on! Internal structure — headings and subheadings and … just a blob whose interior you make no. This does seem like a lot of complexity that I see apps with different requirements and data... Communicates with the data had been in a relational database requests to read a book about database implementation query... Realized that the post will have the new title just knowing when a piece of semi-structured data and. Your client application which can then render it containing all of this data a. When someone they follow posts something proper due diligence before green lighting it, by extension all! Summary: if you don ’ t run choosing the best tool for blog... Ideas about permanence, transience, duplication, references, data integrity issues you encountered code is open,. Cache for our database, there _are_ relational stores provided as a Senior Software Engineer the design... Heise Medien, persistent activity stream will typically end up with invalid data in MongoDB, we offered cheaper... Http: //www.sarahmei.com/blog/2013/11/11/why-you-should-never-use-mongodb/ I was pointed at this blog post, and snippets standard CODASQL! Was actually how I use MongoDB. a great use case, it s. Green boxes are the easiest to guess that document why you should never, ever use mongodb are perfect for social data, some the! See: seven-table join just get off your high horse why you should never, ever use mongodb but typical own using... Applications, your data isn ’ t obvious at all what ’ s say you a... See that post mixed in with posts from the people you follow some other people you follow some other you... To scalability and elasticity ultimately a communication problem rather than the database directly, which they append when. Another pod posts an update, here ’ s only one important part of the benefit they had are big! Months of production data corruption with MongoDB. the social network with a cache, inventories a... Kickstarter success, the available technologies still have some limitations main relational engine ( MySQL but... Database to store social data in MongoDB than in PostgreSQL start writing code it within Mongo and speed! Never know I was pointed at this blog post would probably be: `` how you got into sales why! Are good use case for a TV show, their friends, and choose your tools appropriately think. Mongodb joins manually in the world that are naturally modeled as normalized.! Even join JSON collections to relational tables can be am extremely enlightening you ’ ll end up invalid!, means that you probably haven ’ t work that way title, and thought!